Switching to compact crankset?

8 messages
28/09/2012 at 11:05
How many of you guys and gals are running a compact chainset on your tri bikes and what types of races are you doing? Im contemplating a change as it feels good on my road bike.

I R BABOON
28/09/2012 at 15:04
Can't help I'm afraid

Running doubles on the roadie & TT

Team Laws is a go!!!!

http://www.teamlaws.co.uk

We are live.
28/09/2012 at 16:23
It depends on the type of races you want to do I suppose.

The purpose of a compact chainset is to offer a similar range of lower gear ratios (the ones that make it easy to climb) to a triple chainset but without the added weight of a third ring/triple shifters etc. So if you are going to do some races with seriously big hills (i.e. mountain climbs) then why not... but then why would you if you already have your road bike set up for hills? Keep your TT bike setup for flatter races. It'll still be able to cope with undulating hills. Just an idea

Your call at end of the day, and it's not like you can't change back if you change your mind

gavinp

http://www.trisomi.co.uk

http://www.facebook.com/tri.somi.uk

@triDOTsomi

 

28/09/2012 at 18:29
You make a good point!

I'd just read that having a compact with a 11-23 is essentially the same top speed as a Std with a 12-25, and gives you more on the hills too. Sounded like a winning combo, but now Im not sure..

I R BABOON
28/09/2012 at 19:42
I am a big Compact fan
Unless you cam stay in a 53/11 for long periods you will find that you will mainly be pulling 53/12. A 50/11 is a bigger gear than a 53/12.

A Standard has a 53 or 52 outer and generally a 39 inner but you can get a 42 or a 38
A Compact is generally a 50 outer but I also have a 52. I also have 39, 36 and 34 so oodles of flexibility
Compact has a lower rotational mass

If you are young, injury free than you may want to persevere with a Standard but frankly I think the Compact is a great set up. Get some hill training in with the outer ring, you can always fit a 52 compact . If you have an injury then a Compact with a slightly higher cadence is less stressful.
gearing-triple-double-or-compact-t47459-10.html
Also crank length is important,
post79391.html?hilit=crank%20length#p79391

Hope that helps

It seemed like a good idea at the time!!

Go Team Timmy
28/09/2012 at 20:20
I went from Tripple to compact didnt notice the overal speed distance but did notice i wasnt messing with gears as much.

Dyslexic so apologies for the poor spelling on the posts
28/09/2012 at 21:01
I have a full shimano 105 compact groupset for sale..... only used for 100miles, had it on my new bike I bought (Cannondale Super Six) I wanted the bike and they only sell it with a compact. I have since put my Sram Red groupset on it. might as well say its brand new.
29/09/2012 at 14:26
Good reply from gavinp. Thats what I do.

I put a compact crankset (50/34)and carbon clip ons on my road bike for Ironman France a few years back, intended to swap back but really liked the set up so still have it on now.

Did Ballbuster Duathlon last year and used the compact/road set up for that, perfect.

I use 53/39 on my TT bike.

Ive never noticed any difference in running off either of the bikes.
Your say
email image